Bench Footing vs. Underpinning: Solving Structural Challenges for Toronto Homeowners

Underpinning-and-Benching-Toronto-6-1200x900

Are you tired of ducking under low basement ceilings in your Toronto home? Many older houses in the GTA were built with basements that were never intended for living space, often leaving ceilings under 7 feet high. For homeowners looking to create a livable basement—whether for additional family space, a rental unit, or a home office—raising the height of the basement is essential.

When it comes to increasing basement height, two common methods are bench footing and underpinning. Each has its advantages and challenges, making it important to understand the differences before deciding which option is best for your home.

What Is Bench Footing?

Bench footing is a method of lowering the basement floor by excavating and creating a “bench” along the foundation walls. Instead of extending the existing foundation deeper into the ground, bench footing involves building a new, lower wall inside the existing foundation. This creates a ledge, or bench, where the old and new foundations meet.

Pros of Bench Footing
  • Cost-Effective: Bench footing is typically less expensive than underpinning, making it a good choice for homeowners on a budget.
  • Simpler Process: The construction process is faster and less invasive compared to underpinning.
  • Ideal for Shallow Depth Adjustments: It’s a practical solution when only a small increase in ceiling height is needed.
Cons of Bench Footing
  • Loss of Floor Space: The bench ledge reduces the usable square footage of the basement, which can be a drawback for smaller basements.
  • Aesthetic Impact: The exposed bench can be unsightly and may require additional finishing work to improve its appearance.
  • Limited Depth: Bench footing is less suitable for significant depth adjustments.

Bench footing is often chosen for basements where maximizing headroom is not as critical, or when budget constraints make underpinning less feasible.

BENCH FOOTING tORONTO

What Is Underpinning?

Underpinning (also known as basement lowering) is a more intensive process that involves excavating beneath the existing foundation and extending it deeper into the ground. This allows the entire basement floor to be lowered while maintaining the original walls and maximizing the usable space.

Pros of Underpinning
  • Maximized Space: Unlike bench footing, underpinning does not reduce the basement’s usable square footage.
  • Structural Strength: The process reinforces the foundation, making it stronger and more stable.
  • Greater Depth: Underpinning allows for significant increases in basement height, making it ideal for creating full-height basements.
Cons of Underpinning
  • Higher Cost: Underpinning is more expensive than bench footing due to its complexity and the amount of labor required.
  • Time-Consuming: The process takes longer to complete, which may be a consideration for homeowners with tight timelines.
  • Potential for Neighboring Impact: In areas with close-proximity homes, underpinning can disturb neighboring foundations, requiring additional planning and cost.

Underpinning is the preferred choice for homeowners looking to create a full-height basement without compromising floor space, especially when adding significant depth.

basement-lowering-800x533

Bench Footing vs. Underpinning: Which One Should You Choose?

Deciding between bench footing and underpinning depends on several critical factors, including your budget, the purpose of the basement space, the existing structural conditions, and the depth of the height adjustment required. Here’s a deeper look at the considerations for choosing the right method:

Cost Considerations

  • Bench Footing: Typically, bench footing is the more affordable option. It requires less labor, fewer materials, and a simpler excavation process compared to underpinning. If you’re on a tight budget and need a basic solution for a minor basement renovation or utility space, bench footing can be a cost-effective choice.
  • Underpinning: While more expensive, underpinning provides a longer-lasting solution and adds significant value to your home. For homeowners planning to convert their basement into a livable space, such as a rental unit or additional family area, the higher initial cost of underpinning is often worth the investment.

Space Optimization

  • Bench Footing: The most significant drawback of bench footing is the loss of usable floor space due to the bench ledge that runs along the perimeter of the basement. This reduces square footage, which can be problematic for small basements where every inch counts.
  • Underpinning: Underpinning does not sacrifice floor space, making it the better choice for homeowners who want to maximize the functionality of their basement. By extending the foundation downward, the entire basement floor remains usable.

Structural Impact

  • Bench Footing: Bench footing doesn’t strengthen the existing foundation as underpinning does. While it’s suitable for non-load-bearing walls or basements that don’t require significant structural adjustments, it may not be ideal for older homes with weakened foundations.
  • Underpinning: Underpinning reinforces and stabilizes the existing foundation, making it a superior option for homes experiencing structural issues. In Toronto’s older neighborhoods, where homes often have aging foundations, underpinning is particularly beneficial for ensuring long-term stability.

Depth of Excavation

  • Bench Footing: This method is ideal for shallow depth adjustments. If you only need to gain a few inches of headroom to make the space more functional for storage or limited use, bench footing can be a practical solution.
  • Underpinning: For significant height adjustments (e.g., increasing headroom by a foot or more), underpinning is the only viable choice. It allows for deeper excavation without compromising the integrity of the foundation.

Aesthetic and Functional Goals

  • Bench Footing: The exposed bench created by this method can be aesthetically unappealing and may require additional finishing work to make it blend with the rest of the basement. While it can be covered with drywall or other materials, this adds to the project cost.
  • Underpinning: With no visible changes to the interior walls, underpinning provides a clean, polished look. It’s ideal for homeowners looking to create a finished basement that meets modern design standards.

Use Case Scenarios

To determine the best method for your basement, consider how you plan to use the space:

  • Choose Bench Footing If:
    • You’re working within a limited budget and need a more affordable solution.
    • The basement will primarily be used for storage, laundry, or other utility purposes.
    • Only a slight increase in ceiling height is needed.
    • The aesthetic impact of the bench ledge is not a significant concern.
  • Choose Underpinning If:
    • You want to create a full-height basement suitable for living spaces, such as a rental unit, home gym, or office.
    • Preserving and maximizing usable floor space is a priority.
    • Significant depth adjustments are required to comply with building codes.
    • Your home’s foundation needs reinforcement due to structural instability or aging.

The Importance of Professional Guidance

Both methods require professional expertise to ensure the work is done safely and meets Toronto’s building codes. Factors such as soil type, proximity to neighboring homes, and the condition of the existing foundation play a crucial role in determining the best option. A professional assessment can help identify potential risks and provide recommendations tailored to your home’s specific needs.

Making the Right Choice for Your Basement

Both bench footing and underpinning are effective methods for solving low-ceiling challenges in Toronto basements, but each comes with its own set of pros and cons. Bench footing is a budget-friendly option for smaller height adjustments, while underpinning offers the best results for maximizing space and structural integrity.

If you’re unsure which method is right for your home, the experts at Nusite Group can help. We specialize in basement lowering and foundation solutions for homeowners in Toronto and the GTA. Contact us today for a free consultation, and let us guide you toward the best solution for your basement needs.